NYC Burgers

Buzz Andersen · New York Food Tour · created over 2 years ago

My list of notable burgers (mostly ones I've tried, but a few I still need to) in New York City.

Read more...
  • Guidebadge90px-white

    Follow this guide to find these dishes wherever you go. Upload your own photos to show off the things you've tried.

    Spot All items to earn this badge.
  • Thumb_90

    Mikey's Burger at Mikey's Burger in New York, NY

    A solid fast food style burger with the novel distinction of a corned beef hash topping.

  • Burger at M. Wells in Long Island City, New York

    Beef-lamb blend at a fancy renovated diner opened by some Quebecois expats. Still need to try this one--last time I showed up for dinner only to discover that they're only open for breakfast/lunch/brunch right now.

  • Thumb_90

    Cheeseburger at Peels in New York, NY

    Possibly my favorite NYC burger right now. Really fires on all cylinders and brings together all of the hallmarks of my favorite burgers: potato bun, heavy seasoning, good crust, shredded lettuce, carmelized onions.

  • Thumb_90

    Burger at Burger Joint at Le Parker Meridian in New York, New York

    Hidden burger restaurant in Le Parker Meridien hotel. A quintessential New York experience, and a great fast food style burger.

  • Thumb_90

    Burger at Peter Luger Steakhouse in Brooklyn, NY

    An old school Williamsburg classic. I was skeptical given that steak house burgers often fall short, but it turned out to be great.

  • Thumb_90

    Burger at Prime Meats in Brooklyn, NY

    Still need to try this one, but I hear great things. And with a name like Prime Meats, you know their burger has to be good.

  • Thumb_90

    Cheeseburger at That Burger Tent in Brooklyn, NY

    New pop-up burger restaurant in a tent outside Artists & Fleas in Williamsburg on Saturdays. Fast food style cooked on a portable griddle and featuring a custom Pat LaFrieda blend.

  • Thumb_90

    Lamb Burger at The Breslin in New York, NY

    Easily in my top 5 burgers in New York. The sourdough bun, cumin mayo, and fantastic thrice-cooked steak fries complement the lamb perfectly. An intensely meaty delight.

  • Burger at The Little Owl in New York, New York

    Still need to try this one. Another high end Pat LaFrieda burger that seems to have a cult following.

  • Thumb_90

    Burger at Dram Shop in Brooklyn, NY

    Still need to try this much-loved pub burger.

  • Thumb_90

    Burger at Bill's Bar & Burger in New York, NY

    Not as good as Shake Shack, in my opinion, but still a solid fast food style specimen.

  • Thumb_90

    Black Label Burger at Minetta Tavern in New York, NY

    Probably the most notable NYC burger I haven't tried yet.

  • Thumb_90

    Sliders at St. Anselm in Brooklyn, NY

    A perfect take on the New Jersey style slider. Cooked on a griddle with a bed of onions.

  • Thumb_90

    Burger at Dumont in Brooklyn, NY

    A Williamsburg neighborhood classic, justifiably known for their burgers. Great restaurant style burger with a huge patty. If you ask me, it's the sides (two kinds of house made pickles and really fantastic fries) that make it truly memorable.

  • Thumb_90

    Burger at Pies 'n' Thighs in Brooklyn, New York

    A surprisingly great burger at a place more known for their chicken. Built on a custom beef blend from the Meat Hook.

  • Thumb_90

    Burger at Five Leaves in Brooklyn, NY

    Skip the crazy Australian style burger and go straight for their super solid old fashioned model.

  • Thumb_90

    Burger at Diner in Brooklyn, NY

    One of my personal favorites. Some people think it's too salty, but I like a lot of seasoning on my burgers. Manages to have a healthy crust and still be plenty juicy.

  • Thumb_90

    Shack Burger at Shake Shack in New York, NY

    The Classic. The apotheosis of the fast food burger style. If you only eat one burger on your trip to New York, make it this one.